Wednesday, January 19, 2005

The Counterterrorism Blog: The enemy within

The Counterterrorism Blog: The enemy within... an enemy with little more than a label and a set of somewhat anti-social beliefs. But how big is this threat, in terms of numbers of people, and cohesion of purpose? Any army has dissidents, or members with hidden/different agendas. The question is whether and how they choose to act on those agendas. Belief-screening troops contradicts the very cause for which they are supposedly fighting.

Just because a band of madmen managed to coordinate themselves enough to circumvent woefully slack security and execute the action movie-insane plot to use airlines as missiles, it doesn't mean that the enemy are everywhere, or, indeed, coordinated. Whatever your moral standing on the justification of war in Iraq (for the record, I believe it was ethically right but legally wrong), it has proved to be a useful honeypot for those of an anti-American persuasion. Useful to both factions: the terrorists get the attention they crave, and the allies lure the terrorists away from their homelands and into a theatre of war - albeit a complex and over-stretched theatre. Given this focus, are the draconian security measures imposed in the US really necessary? Will the pioneer's right to bear arms and defend himself prove to suppress his right (and subsequent ability) to express himself with anything other than weapons?

'Fear is the mind-killer'. Spreading fear for political expediency (maybe not maliciously, maybe just to cover their asses) has the unfortunate long-term effect of numbing the senses and degrading the traditions of community that hold a society together. In effect, it plays to the objectives of the terrorists. Since the 60's Americans have gained a stereotype of being patronisingly naive - comparing other nations to the US and always finding them wanting, rather than pleasingly different. In its new-found age of irony, it seems the nation of extremes has taken this concept to its extreme: it is comparing itself to itself and finding it wanting.

America is a nation based on little more than ideology - the familiar melting-pot cliche. While ideology is a powerful force, it requires, like a superhero, a nemesis. Otherwise, it is just so much muscle and lycra.

No comments: