Monday, July 12, 2004

Article on comics as a viable literary medium

The New York Times > Magazine > Not Funnies


Being a fairly ardent fan of comics myself, I agree with much of what this writer has to say. To me, comics (or graphic novels, or whatever) appeal to something primeval in us - much like cave paintings or hieroglyphics. They are the simplification of reality to tell a story. I actually find many novels, even modern ones, quite the reverse: complication, excessive detailing of reality.


In the modern era of film and tv, imaginations are becoming harder and more expensive to stretch - not just because the attention span of your average punter is under constant assault, but also because barriers to reality have been 'virtually' removed (pun intended) by computer graphics.


I actually believe that comics are poetry to film's theatre. They adhere to the golden poetic principle that less is more, and that the results give very little indication of the effort. It could take years to create a 50-page graphic novel, or a single poem. In this sense I actually think they are more literary than novels, where anyone with an english degree and an interesting subject can prognosticate their way to awards. Novels are a stale medium - not dead, just formulaic.


Comics are multimedia, in that they are dealing with prose and vision, and it is no accident that most films these days are storyboarded - graphic artists sketching the scene sequences. Yet the best ones stand out in their own medium greater than any other. Any adaptation detracts from the original. As with any emerging art form, the range in quality can be quite erratic. But in an increasingly digital world, where even that most personal of touches, the signature, is endangered, I think more emphasis needs to be put on individual styling. And in terms of storytelling, there's no better medium.

No comments: