Friday, October 31, 2003

Slashdot | Microsoft's new CLI



Microsoft going back to the command line. It's the 3 ages of technology again, isn't it?

Stage 1: a prototype, effectively - barely fulfilling design criteria, and certainly not robustly.

Stage 2: over-design. They've got the hang of it, they've got a market, so they pack it full of features until it becomes cumbersome.

Stage 3: just right - removal of extraneous features.



To a unix-head stage 3 is the command line. I'm no unix head, but I do appreciate the elegant simplicity of Unix: everything is in a file. So, all the settings are in a file, which you can tweak either through some pretty GUI screens with checkboxes and tabs, or through the CLI by editing the file directly. Non-Unix people say, "but unix is so user-unfriendly. Who wants a command line? It's so indecipherable." My response, as one who is not a techie but has a sincere respect for techies and technology, is simply if you're playing with settings you should explicitly know what they do.



The other advantage of a file-based system (as in, you tweak files directly, rather than use wizards that give no indication of which file you're tweaking), is that you can make changes easily reversible by the use of comments - something woefully lacking in GUIs. Finally, it also means you just need Telnet to tweak any online server in the world. None of this Remote Windows Desktop foolishness. Mind you, whether this degree of tweakability is healthy in an OS with Windows' security record is questionable.

Monday, October 13, 2003

silicon.com - ITU 03 - Microsoft wants to make Wi-Fi hotspots more secure



I would say 'about bloody time', but instead I have to say that network security should stay on the network, not as part of some OS somewhere.



Part of the problem with the microsoft OS paradigm is that the OS is treated with such a degree of profundity, rather than the basic enabler between software and hardware that it should be. Most non-technical people actually believe the OS is the graphical bit, the user interface. And this suits Microsoft perfectly. Even those banes of M$ strategy, Linux users, tend to play into their hands by playing up the OS wars, rather than changing the argument and putting OSes in their place as merely the bit of software that gets hardware to talk to software.



If there's a problem with the network (eg. it's not secure), it should stay a network problem and the network kit vendors should solve their problem. But software is cheaper than hardware, and evolves faster - that's why we have it - so invariably the hardware people leave it to the software people to set their standards and pick the most viable one to implement in hardware. Unfortunately, this leads to a self-perpetuating lead for the prominent OS vendor, since, more often than not, the most viable standard is the most popular, as implemented in the most popular OS, rather than the best technology.

Sunday, September 28, 2003

The Register, 26/08/2003: Microsoft: a threat to global IT and job security?

V interesting article speculating about a piece of security research slating Microsoft, for which the author lost his job. Interesting discussion - esp. about possible remedies.

Friday, September 26, 2003

CNN.com - Makers of Kazaa suing record labels - Sep. 24, 2003



Now, this should make things interesting. I wonder if the RIAA will show as much respect to software copyright as they expect everyone to show to music copyright? Live by the sword, die by the sword...

Wednesday, September 24, 2003

Slashdot | Is There An OS On My Hard Drive?



Now this is how OSes should have always been sold. Buy your kit, then choose the hard disk, with whichever OS you like on it. Windows as standard has just made the whole world less secure - a bit like US culture as standard. The best is not the same as none better.



Report: Microsoft dominance poses security risk | CNET News.com



Now, here's a tyre shredder in the path of M$'s drive on security. In their defence, security through obscurity is not security: sure, their OS is a target, but that's a reason for them to fix things. Most security experts will tell you that if you want real security, look elsewhere. I suppose their concern is that people don't realise how unsecure their systems are with M$ products.

Tuesday, September 23, 2003

Art Watch - September 7, 2003 - MP3s Are Not the Devil - Orson Scott Card

Art Watch - September 7, 2003 - MP3s Are Not the Devil - The Ornery American

Here, Orson Scott Card a renowned and respected author, whose livelihood depends on copyright, argues against the recording studios and, more importantly, offers some solutions.
BW Online | September 29, 2003 | Howard Rheingold, Author of Smart Mobs



I remember reading a much earlier book of his describing the early days of the internet, and the uses which people were putting it to. Future historians will look back on this guy as the Tacitus of the Internet.

Wednesday, September 17, 2003

ZDNet UK - News - Another survey rates Microsoft cheaper than Linux



I'm as sceptical as the next anti-M$ person, but the fact remains that linux on the desktop PC isn't in the market. Where I see it potentially making headroads is through the network admin and applications markets. Most corporate users use maybe 5 apps on their systems. If you remove the need for these apps to be MS-based, users don't care which desktop they're running. But IT managers still do, so you need to beef up the enterprise desktop admin tools too.



Then, who cares what OS you're running? That's how it always should have been. To use your car analogy, who cares what engine management system they have in their car? Most people don't even know.

Thursday, September 11, 2003

Software copyright: something's got to give... and I think I know where my money is.
ZDNet UK - News - Open-source leaders: 'We are accountable'

The whole thing is hilarious, yet profound. SCO want to sue people for using their code, which they're not prepared to reveal. Can we sue M$ for producing Paint - remarkably similar to a graphics project Tony, Rob & I did at uni? Oh no, that's a product, whereas this case is about lines of code!

In which case, can I copyright this sentence? There, I've typed it. Now don't you go using that Copy button now…!

Strange that the event that woke SCO up (they were teetering on bankruptcy) was Microsoft paying them a wedge of money for some unix licensing rights… or for spreading some FUD on linux? Conspiracy, anyone?

I've been waiting some time for the copyleft to meet the copyright, but I didn't think it would happen so bizarrely…!